Being a bit of a fan of the first series, I made the mistake of going into an anime with a “Yeah, this is going to be great” attitude, something I always tell myself to do. In retrospect, this would have been one of the better times to do it.
The first FMA episode seems to have a mixed audience going into it, making it that much harder. You have newcomers, who’ve heard of FMA before and want to see what it’s all about. You have the anime-only watchers, who are inclined to see the “real” story behind the anime. And we have the manga readers, who have a good idea where the plot should be heading.
FMA seems like its trying to cater to all of these audiences, and they might not be doing a great job of it because of that. Newcomers are treated to spoilers in the opening about Ed losing his arm and leg through alchemy, while Al lost his whole body. Yet, the opening doesn’t really show much to manga readers, and, compared to the more RAH-RAH energetic openings of the first run, it has a more serious, dramatic spin to it, rather than the sort of adventurous action/drama that it had before. It’s not a bad opening (I actually think it’s pretty decent), but I think it might have a better impact as a SECOND opening, after the whole FMA gets settled into the viewers’ systems.
In terms of the episode itself, it seems like it’s all over the place. Previous watchers are bored as random character introductions are done again and again. I don’t think my friend Kyokushi will be very happy about Roy Mustang’s new voice. It isn’t bad, per se, but it’s definitely “just different enough” to notice the dissimilarity. I’m glad that there’s still comedic sequences, but it seems almost a bit exaggerated and out-of-place, as if their trying to say, “Hey dumb viewers! Remember this gag from the first run?!” Yeah, we remember, please don’t grind it into our face. >_> There’s a good amount of action, and they probably do a better job of pulling off reveals (Al and Ed’s bodies) than stuff they did earlier. I give characterization a C+.
On the positive side, the animation is a little different, but easy on the eyes. Some of camera angles and choreography is a little overdone, though. Yes, I get to see the Crimson Alchemist’s cell in HIGH-DEFINITION, BUT I DON’T CARE ABOUT HIS STATIC-SCREEN CELL. I understand that production companies have a tight budget in such times, but some more simply drawn, close-angled shots with a more artistic nature might work better. Colors, though are good, vibrant when it needs to be, dark and foggy when you’re in the cold, cold streets of Central. Gives plenty of atmosphere. B+
The music. Music? Didn’t seem to stand out, but I guess it therefore wasn’t bad, either. Voice acting was decent enough, but nothing spectacular. I’m glad that Ed and Al sound pretty much the same as before (with acceptable aging differences), otherwise I would have a hard time getting over the change with Mustang. I give it a B-.
Plot and pacing-wise, as mentioned, it was a bit all over the place, and seemed more like a TV special than the start of a new series. As mentioned before, they seem to be hitting three very different groups at the same time. The first half is relatively spastic and disconnected. The second half, however, seems to gain momentum with the action, where it’s probably strongest. The fight with the Ice Alchemist kinda’ gets you excited about what else this guy can do with water in the middle of battle, and how Ed and Al can overcome his abilities. It saddens me, though that Mustang is presented more comically than dramatic during his action sequences, thereby somewhat ruining the “cool” factor that he has. B-.
Now that my opinion of the show is a bit more down, I can at least hope for things to get better. Rehashes and remakes aren’t really my thing (with the special exception of the Shana movie).
We’ll see what happens. As everyone who knows me already (or now) knows, I tend to be much more forgiving of anime than most people.